If you’re shopping for a compact kitchen appliance that can handle quick and easy cooking, you’ve probably found yourself stuck in the air fryer vs toaster oven debate. Both appliances are versatile, energy-efficient, and can save you time in the kitchen—but which one is right for you?
The answer depends on your cooking habits, kitchen space, and the types of meals you love to prepare. Do you crave crispy, fried-like foods with little to no oil? An air fryer might be your best bet. Or do you need a multi-purpose appliance for baking, roasting, and toasting? A toaster oven could be the better choice.
In this detailed comparison, we’ll break down the key differences, advantages, and drawbacks of both appliances. By the end, you’ll have a clear idea of which one suits your needs best. Let’s dive in!
Basics of Air Fryer and Toaster Oven
Before choosing between an air fryer and a toaster oven, it’s important to understand how each appliance works and what it brings to the table. While both can handle tasks like reheating and roasting, their cooking methods and primary functions are quite different.
What Is an Air Fryer?
An air fryer is a compact countertop appliance designed to mimic deep frying—but without the excess oil. It works by circulating hot air rapidly around the food, creating a crispy outer layer while keeping the inside tender. This process, known as rapid air circulation, delivers a fried-like texture with a fraction of the calories and fat found in traditional frying.
Air fryers are especially popular for making crispy fries, chicken wings, and roasted vegetables. Many models also come with additional functions like baking, roasting, and even dehydrating, making them surprisingly versatile despite their smaller size.
There are two main types of air fryers:
- Basket-style air fryers, which resemble small convection ovens with a pull-out drawer for food placement.
- Oven-style air fryers, which look more like traditional toaster ovens and often have multiple racks for cooking different foods at once.
While air fryers shine when it comes to crispy, fast-cooking meals, their smaller cooking capacity can be a downside for those cooking for multiple people.
What Is a Toaster Oven?
A toaster oven is essentially a miniature oven that sits on your countertop. It uses heating elements (either coils or quartz heating technology) to cook food, similar to a conventional oven. Some models also feature convection technology, which circulates hot air for faster and more even cooking—bringing them closer to air fryer performance.
Toaster ovens are incredibly versatile. You can use them for baking, roasting, broiling, reheating, and, of course, toasting. Whether you’re making a small batch of cookies, reheating last night’s pizza, or roasting vegetables, a toaster oven can handle it all.
Unlike air fryers, toaster ovens generally have a larger capacity, making them ideal for preparing meals for families or multiple servings at once. Many models can fit a 12-inch pizza or even a small whole chicken, making them a great alternative to turning on a full-sized oven.
However, while they can crisp food, they may not achieve the same deep-fried texture that air fryers are known for.
Comparison Table – Air Fryer vs Toaster Oven
To make your decision easier, here’s a side-by-side comparison of the key differences between an air fryer and a toaster oven. This table highlights important factors like cooking performance, speed, versatility, and ease of use.
| Feature | Air Fryer | Toaster Oven |
| Cooking Method | Rapid air circulation (like convection baking but faster) | Heating elements (like a mini oven, some with convection) |
| Best For | Crispy, fried-like foods (fries, wings, nuggets, roasted veggies) | Baking, roasting, toasting, reheating, and general cooking |
| Crispiness Level | Excellent – mimics deep frying with little to no oil | Good – can crisp but not as effectively as an air fryer |
| Cooking Speed | Faster – Preheats quickly and cooks in less time | Slower – Takes longer to heat up and cook food |
| Versatility | Good – Can roast, bake, and dehydrate (depending on the model) but mainly designed for crisping | Excellent – Can bake, toast, broil, roast, and reheat a variety of foods |
| Cooking Capacity | Smaller – Best for individuals or small servings | Larger – Can cook bigger meals, fit a 12” pizza, or even roast a small chicken |
| Health Benefits | Uses little to no oil, making it a healthier alternative to frying | Doesn’t require much oil but won’t mimic deep-fried textures as well |
| Ease of Use | Simple presets and digital controls make it user-friendly | Requires manual temperature and time adjustments, but still easy to use |
| Ease of Cleaning | Easier – Non-stick baskets are often dishwasher-safe | Harder – Racks and trays collect crumbs and grease, requiring more cleanup |
| Noise Level | Noisy – High-speed fan can be loud | Quiet – Operates like a traditional oven |
| Size & Counter Space | Compact – Great for small kitchens, RVs, or dorms | Larger – Takes up more counter space but offers more functionality |
| Energy Efficiency | High – Cooks quickly and uses less electricity | Moderate – Uses more energy due to longer cook times |
| Price Range | $50 – $300 (varies by size and features) | $50 – $400 (varies by size and features) |
Key Differences Between Air Fryers and Toaster Ovens
Now that you understand how air fryers and toaster ovens work, let’s dive into their key differences. While both appliances can cook, reheat, and crisp food, their cooking methods, efficiency, and overall versatility set them apart. Here’s how they compare across different factors.
Cooking Technology
The biggest difference between an air fryer and a toaster oven is how they generate heat and cook food.
Air fryers use rapid air circulation technology, which works like a high-speed convection oven. A powerful fan circulates hot air around the food at high speeds, creating a crispy outer layer similar to deep frying—but with significantly less oil. The compact size of an air fryer also helps maintain high heat, ensuring food cooks quickly and evenly.
Toaster ovens, on the other hand, rely on heating elements—either coils or quartz heating rods—to generate heat, similar to a traditional oven. Some models include convection settings, where a fan distributes hot air throughout the oven to improve cooking efficiency. However, even with a convection feature, toaster ovens don’t achieve the same level of crispiness as an air fryer due to their slower air circulation and larger cooking space.
Cooking Performance & Versatility
When it comes to versatility, toaster ovens have the upper hand. They can handle a wider variety of cooking tasks, including baking, roasting, broiling, toasting, and reheating. Whether you want to toast bread, bake cookies, or roast a whole chicken, a toaster oven can do it all. Some higher-end models even offer specialized settings for pizza, bagels, and slow roasting.
Air fryers, while excellent for crisping foods, are more limited in versatility. They work best for foods that benefit from rapid hot air circulation, such as French fries, chicken wings, onion rings, and roasted vegetables. Many air fryers do have baking and roasting functions, but their compact size makes them less practical for larger meals. You won’t be able to bake a full cake or roast a whole chicken as easily as you would in a toaster oven.
Cooking Speed & Efficiency
Air fryers generally cook food faster than toaster ovens due to their compact size and high-powered fan. Because they don’t require much preheating, you can start cooking almost immediately, cutting down overall cook time. Foods like frozen fries, chicken tenders, and vegetables can be cooked in as little as 10-15 minutes, compared to 20-30 minutes in a toaster oven.
Toaster ovens, while still faster than traditional ovens, take longer to heat up and cook food compared to air fryers. They rely on heating elements, which take time to reach the desired temperature. If you’re in a rush and need to whip up a quick snack, an air fryer is the better choice. However, for foods that require slow, even cooking (like baked goods or casseroles), a toaster oven is the more suitable option.
Health & Nutrition (Is an air fryer healthier than a toaster oven?)
One of the biggest reasons people choose air fryers is their ability to cook crispy foods with little to no oil. Instead of submerging food in oil like traditional frying, an air fryer uses hot air to create a crunchy texture. This means you can enjoy fried-like foods with fewer calories and less fat, making it a healthier alternative to deep frying.
Toaster ovens don’t necessarily require oil either, but they don’t provide the same crispy results as an air fryer. When roasting or baking in a toaster oven, you may need to use butter or oil to enhance flavor and texture, especially for vegetables and meats.
If you’re looking for the healthiest cooking option, an air fryer is the winner—especially for those who love crispy, fried-style foods but want to cut down on excess fats. However, for dishes that require slow, even heating (such as baked chicken, casseroles, or roasted vegetables), a toaster oven still offers a healthy way to cook without needing excessive oil.
Space & Kitchen Suitability (Toaster oven or air fryer for small kitchen?)
Kitchen space is an important factor, especially for those with small kitchens, dorm rooms, RVs, or limited counter space.
Air fryers are generally more compact than toaster ovens, making them a great fit for smaller kitchens. Basket-style models take up very little counter space, making them ideal for those with limited room. However, oven-style air fryers (which look like mini toaster ovens) can be bulkier and take up just as much space as a traditional toaster oven.
Toaster ovens, while still considered small appliances, are typically larger and bulkier than air fryers. They require more counter space and may not be ideal for tiny kitchens. However, if you need an appliance that can do more (bake, toast, and roast), the extra space requirement might be worth it.
If you have limited space, a basket-style air fryer is the better option. But if you can afford to sacrifice a bit more counter space for added versatility, a toaster oven might be worth considering.
Ease of Use & Cleaning
When it comes to convenience, air fryers are easier to use and clean. Most air fryers have simple digital controls with pre-set cooking functions, so you can just select a setting and let it do the work. Cleaning is also straightforward—most air fryer baskets are non-stick and dishwasher-safe, making cleanup a breeze.
Toaster ovens, while not difficult to use, require manual temperature and time adjustments for different foods. Cleaning can also be trickier, as crumbs and grease can accumulate on the racks and trays. Some models come with removable crumb trays, but they still require more effort to keep clean compared to an air fryer.
If you prioritize ease of use and cleaning, the air fryer wins. But if you don’t mind a little extra maintenance for a more versatile appliance, a toaster oven remains a solid choice.
Recommended For You: Air Fryer vs Deep Fryer
Pros and Cons of Air Fryers vs. Toaster Ovens
Now that we’ve explored the key differences between air fryers and toaster ovens, let’s take a closer look at the advantages and disadvantages of each appliance. Whether you prioritize health benefits, cooking versatility, or ease of use, this section will help you weigh the pros and cons before making your decision.
Pros & Cons of an Air Fryer
Pros:
- Healthier Cooking with Less Oil – Air fryers use rapid air circulation to achieve a crispy texture without requiring large amounts of oil, making them a healthier alternative to deep frying.
- Faster Cooking Times – The compact design and high-powered fan allow air fryers to cook food quickly, often in half the time it would take in a traditional oven or toaster oven.
- Ideal for Crispy Foods – If you love crunchy fries, crispy chicken wings, or golden mozzarella sticks, an air fryer delivers a texture that’s hard to achieve in a toaster oven.
- Compact and Space-Saving – Basket-style air fryers are smaller than most toaster ovens, making them perfect for small kitchens, dorm rooms, and RVs.
- Easy to Use & Clean – Most air fryers have simple digital controls with pre-set functions, and their non-stick baskets are dishwasher-safe, making cleanup a breeze.
Cons:
- Limited Cooking Capacity – Most air fryers (especially basket-style models) have small cooking chambers, which may not be ideal for large families or batch cooking.
- Not Great for Baking or Roasting – While air fryers can technically bake and roast, their compact size limits their ability to handle larger dishes like cakes, casseroles, or whole chickens.
- Some Models Can Be Noisy – Because air fryers use a high-speed fan to circulate hot air, they can be noisier than a traditional toaster oven, especially when running at high temperatures.
Pros & Cons of a Toaster Oven
Pros:
- More Versatile Cooking Options – Toaster ovens can toast, bake, broil, roast, and reheat a wide range of foods, making them a more flexible kitchen appliance.
- Larger Cooking Capacity – With multiple rack positions and a larger cooking chamber, toaster ovens can handle bigger meals, making them great for families or batch cooking.
- Better for Baking & Roasting – Unlike air fryers, toaster ovens can bake cakes, cookies, and casseroles with even heat distribution. They can also roast meats and vegetables more effectively.
- Can Function as a Secondary Oven – If you don’t want to turn on your full-sized oven for smaller meals, a toaster oven provides a great alternative for energy-efficient cooking.
- Less Noise During Cooking – Unlike air fryers, toaster ovens don’t rely on a high-speed fan, making them quieter when in operation.
Cons:
- Longer Cooking Times – Toaster ovens take longer to cook food than air fryers because they don’t use rapid air circulation to speed up the process.
- Not as Good for Crispy Foods – While some toaster ovens have a convection function, they don’t achieve the same level of crispiness as an air fryer, especially for fried-style foods.
- Takes Up More Counter Space – Toaster ovens are bulkier than air fryers, which can be a disadvantage if you have limited kitchen space.
- Cleaning Can Be More Time-Consuming – Toaster ovens often accumulate crumbs, grease, and residue on their racks and trays, requiring more effort to clean than an air fryer.
If you’re still unsure which one is the better kitchen appliance for your needs, check out our detailed comparison on Air Fryer vs Microwave: Which Is Better? for an in-depth analysis of their pros and cons.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
If you’re still unsure whether an air fryer or a toaster oven is the right choice for you, these commonly asked questions can help clarify things.
Can a toaster oven replace an air fryer?
It depends on what you cook most often. If you mainly use an air fryer for reheating, baking, or roasting, a toaster oven can perform similar functions. However, if you love crispy, fried-like foods, a toaster oven won’t fully replace an air fryer, as it doesn’t circulate air as aggressively to achieve the same crunch. If you have a convection toaster oven, it can get close, but it still won’t replicate the rapid air frying technology.
Which is better for baking – air fryer or toaster oven?
A toaster oven is better for baking because it provides a larger cooking space and more even heat distribution. You can bake cookies, cakes, muffins, and even pizza in a toaster oven. While some air fryer models have a baking function, their smaller size makes it harder to bake larger batches or certain baked goods evenly. If baking is a priority, a toaster oven is the better choice.
Does an air fryer cook faster than a toaster oven?
Yes, an air fryer cooks faster because it uses rapid air circulation to heat food quickly. It also requires little to no preheating, while a toaster oven usually takes a few minutes to warm up before cooking. Foods like frozen fries, chicken wings, and vegetables will typically cook twice as fast in an air fryer compared to a toaster oven.
Can you toast bread in an air fryer?
Yes, you can toast bread in an air fryer, but it’s not as effective as a toaster oven. An air fryer may toast bread unevenly and lack dedicated toast settings that allow you to control browning levels. If toasting bread, bagels, or English muffins is a priority, a toaster oven is the better appliance.
Which appliance is easier to clean – air fryer or toaster oven?
Air fryers are generally easier to clean because most models have non-stick, dishwasher-safe baskets that require minimal scrubbing. Toaster ovens, on the other hand, accumulate crumbs, grease, and food residue on their trays and racks, requiring more frequent cleaning. If ease of cleaning is a major factor for you, an air fryer is the better choice.
Can I cook frozen foods on both appliances?
Yes, both appliances can cook frozen foods, but an air fryer is faster and better at crisping. Frozen fries, nuggets, and other snacks cook quickly in an air fryer without needing extra oil. A toaster oven can also handle frozen foods but may take longer to achieve a crispy texture.
Final Verdict – Which One Should You Buy?
Both air fryers and toaster ovens have their strengths, but the right choice depends on your cooking habits, kitchen space, and personal preferences.
- If you love crispy, fried-style foods, want a healthier cooking option with minimal oil, and need faster cooking times, an air fryer is the way to go. It’s ideal for quick meals, reheating leftovers, and getting that perfect crunch without deep frying.
- If you need a versatile appliance that can toast, bake, broil, and reheat larger meals, a toaster oven is the better investment. It’s great for baking cookies, roasting meats, and even replacing a traditional oven for small-scale cooking.
Best for Small Kitchens?
If counter space is limited, a compact air fryer is a more space-saving option. However, if you want an all-in-one cooking appliance, a toaster oven (especially a convection model) can replace multiple kitchen gadgets.
Can’t Decide? Get a Hybrid!
Still torn between the two? Many modern toaster ovens now come with built-in air frying functions, giving you the best of both worlds. A convection toaster oven with an air fryer setting offers crispier results than a standard toaster oven while maintaining its versatility.
Final Thought: Choose Based on Your Cooking Priorities
- For speed, crispiness, and healthier meals → Get an air fryer.
- For versatility, larger cooking capacity, and baking → Get a toaster oven.
- For both crispiness and versatility → Consider an air fryer toaster oven combo.
Whichever you choose, both appliances can be game-changers in your kitchen, making cooking faster, easier, and more enjoyable!
You May Also Like: Cosori vs Ninja Air Fryer
